Ketogenic Diets or Diabetes Breathalyzer False Positive

  • ABOUT OUR FIRM

    Robert L. Miller and Associates is a law firm dedicated to clients. We have handled thousands of cases, and have winning results. Learn more about our firm and why it’s the best choice.

    Read more

  • CASE RESULTS

    DUI Dismissals and Case Results
    See some of the many cases we have won at trial or through motions, negotiations, or strategy. Learn why we are so successful in protecting clients

    Read more

  • CONTACT US NOW...

    If you have been arrested, don’t delay. You have only 10 days to save your license. Contact us today for a FREE consultation, and find out about all of your options, and all of your rights, and how to protect yourself.

    Read more

Ketogenic Diets or Diabetes Breathalyzer False Positive

Ketogenic Diets or Diabetes Breathalyzer False Positive.

Was the breathalyzer in my DUI case operating properly?
Persons that are on ketogenic diets, or in ketosis due to high protein low carb diets can have false positives. Also, diabetics experiencing ketoacidosis may produce endogenous acetone, which may even, in turn, metabolize into ispropanol alcohol. Ketogenic Diets or Diabetes Breathalyzer False Positive is a problem.
Breath testing devices might better be characterized as relatively specific for detecting ethanol, as practically applied in breath tests of live human subjects.
Consider three types of alcohol breath instruments :

1. SEMICONDUCTOR TECHNOLOGY BREATHALYZERS

 The cheapest portable breath testers (PBTs) and some ignition interlock devices use semiconductor technology. These are likely the kind you might buy at Radio Shack as a novelty. I believe that these devices can’t quickly-enough-for-an-instant-test distinguish between ethyl (drinking) alcohol and its chemical cousins, such as isopropyl alcohol, methyl alcohol, toluene, and maybe acetone (which is a keytone). Such a PBT may indiscriminately and cumulatively measure ethyl alcohol and its cousins, if present.
 
Therefore, a cousin of ethyl alcohol could, by itself, be the source of a false positive for ethyl alcohol. Further, it could be combined with any present ethyl alcohol to result in anelevated positive.

2. FUEL CELL TECHNOLOGY IS RELATIVELY SPECIFIC

 More expensive PBTs use fuel cell technology. These are the kind that law enforcement is likely to use in the field. An example of a fuel cell PBT is the Intoxilyzer SD-5. Its operator’s manual at page 23 under “specificity,” declares: “The detector is unaffected by acetone, paint and glue fumes, foods, confectionery, methane, and practically all other non-alcoholic substances at the levels found in human breath.” (Emphasis added.)
 
Granted, this is a disclaimer by a very interested party, the manufacturer.  But note that it doesn’t claim total specificity.
 
At the very least, fuel cells are relatively specific to ethyl (drinking) alcohol. While fuel cells may react to non-ethyl alcohols, perhaps even those such as acetone found in human breath, they do so at a slower rate, according to Hansueli Ryser, executive director of Draeger Safety Diagnostics Inc., a manufacturer of breath-testing devices.
 
Perhaps that reaction is too slow (or too slight) to make any practical difference in an instantaneous reading.  Perhaps to register, the amount of the interferant cousin of ethanol must be so high that it couldn’t exist on the breath of a living, breathing human.
 
The science, and the machines, don’t know where to place sorbitol or xylitol as a sugar alcohol which can create a false positive in the spectrum of the alcohol family.

3. SPECTROSCOPIC TECHNOLOGY IS MORE SPECIFIC

 Modern evidential breath-testing machines, such as the type used in Orange County DUI breath cases, employing infrared spectroscopy with chopper wheels and/or pulsing light sources, can allow them to distinguish ethyl alcohol from potential interferants, its chemical cousins.
 
Perhaps an exception would be where the ethanol reading may be slightly elevated because of a false positive vector from isopropanol.

Our Mission: "To deliver outstanding client service, to provide fulfilling careers and professional satisfaction for our people, and to achieve financial success so that we can reward ourselves, grow, and give back to the community."